Here’s a recipe for restaurant success: Take one part BOKA Restaurant Group (the influential folks behind GT Fish & Oyster, Girl & The Goat, and BOKA), then add one part The Bristol (including Jean Banchet Award-winner Chris Pandel and pastry chef extraordinaire Amanda Rockman), plus a generous dash of sexy interior design and a great location. Mix them together and let it marinate for a few months, and you have Balena.
The newly-opened Italian restaurant takes the place of Landmark Grill, a past-its-prime pre-theater staple across from the Steppenwolf. After BOKA Group was through sprucing up the place, it feels totally new. The rustic pizzas that Chris Pandel is whipping up in the wood-burning oven are great, and Amanda Rockman’s desserts are as tasty as the ones she produces for The Bristol. In short, they’re getting nearly everything right.
We began our meal with a family-style platter of meats, cheeses, and bread. The charcuterie comes from Smoking Goose, a small company in Indianapolis that buys meat from local farmers like Gunthorp, Carley, and Seven Sons, and then turns it into sausages, smoked meats, and larder meats. I especially liked the paprika cured pork, and the juniper-spiced salumi was an intriguing spin on a classic sausage. All the breads on the plate are baked in-house by a chef named Peter, who also makes Balena’s pastas.
After devouring the charcuterie plate, we noticed a unique pizza on the menu: a “Lasagna Pie” with bolognese sauce, ricotta, and basil. Our server explained that when chef Chris was working in restaurants in New York City, he would often work so late that the only place open for dinner at that hour was a pizza spot, where a specialty “lasagna pizza” was Chris’s go-to. In homage, he’s made his own version, which is topped with a slightly sweet bolognese sauce.
Of course, we knew to leave room for dessert. Amanda Rockman’s gelatos were excellent, especially a very memorable chocolate flavor with olive oil powder and sea salt. The pistachio flavor was a close second. Somehow, we also put away a caramel pine nut tart and a rich chocolate budino with amaro and fior di latte (cow mozzarella).
I chose to recreate Balena’s charcuterie plate because the sausages really stood out to me. While the fresh-baked breads were also excellent, they were so unique that I thought it might be impossible to recreate them properly for the shot. We concentrated on the meats here, adding a sheet of parchment paper under the slices to give them a freshly shaved look. Photographing meat can be difficult for a few reasons: First, it can look too dry, which is why we try to shoot it fairly quickly on set. On the other hand, it can also look too greasy, which isn’t appealing either. In that case, we use cosmetic oil absorbing sheets (from the drugstore) to take off some of the extra sheen. Lastly, meat can very easily look too heavy in photographs, especially when you’re including this many types in one shot. To combat that, I kept the light bright and natural, and added some green and yellow accents for freshness.




























